Black Water Hydro and Community Energy Update

in Our Environment

As many of you may know the G&D Community Energy Group have been looking into the feasibility of a small scale Hydro on the Black Water River near Silverbridge.

Community owned Energy Generation

At the time we held the outdoor meeting “Exploring Community Owned Electricity Generation” back in July, we were about to apply for external funding to support the Hydro project. The funding would pay for work needed to consider the environmental impact and give us an initial cost/benefit analysis for the identified potential development at Black Water River. This, and of course full community support, was essential before we could move any further forward.

Our application to the Scottish Government's Community and Renewable Energy Scheme (CARES) was not successful. Although CARES were positive about the Energy Group and were keen for Local Energy Scotland to work with us to consider any new project for the future, they said that “commercial and consenting viability of the hydro was very low”.

One of the factors affecting current ‘viability’ is that feeding power from a new generation scheme into the National Grid is currently restricted to around 50kW (well below what might have been possible on the basis of the ‘walk around’ of the Black water river), and whilst our application identified an number of ‘local/community’ uses for any ‘surplus’ power, we (working with the TGDDC) have yet to establish a business case and support for a number of our/your ideas that might have made the difference! (Car & eBike charging, a community Café, an outdoor centre etc.).

However, feedback from the recent Community Development Plan review may support progress on some of these ‘projects’ and justify a review of this and other Community Generation schemes in the not too distant future. In the meantime, Ewan will ask CARES for a full feedback report which will be useful when seeking funding for future projects.

So, whilst the outcome from our first CARES application is disappointing, the benefits to the community that our own Renewable Energy could deliver, remain valid. i.e. – Working towards a ‘Net Zero Carbon’ community, employment opportunities and income generation via projects that generate and use ‘our own’ power.

We’ll be holding a “Zoom” event where you’ll be able to ask questions and discuss what we could and should do next for community owned renewable energy generation. There’ll also be a presentation of why we were unable to progress the Community Hydro project.

Community support and approval is always needed, and sought, before we can take Community Benefit projects forward. Thank you to all who have supported the project and to those who have let the Energy Group know about their concerns. For any project in the Development Plan to succeed, feedback is always needed from all who have a view whether it’s for or against. It’s the only way we can all engage and move forward as a community.

Downloads

TOP

Last updated: Wed 22 Apr 2026, 10:41