
Why do community organisations' boards need a health check?
in The Garve & District Development Company
The importance of health applies to all aspects of life, it therefore stands to reason that is applies to board governance too!
Board Governance Health Check
During April 2022, The Development Company were pleased to be accepted as part of Highland and Islands Enterprise Board Health Check, Skills and Training Programme managed by Impact Hub, Inverness. We worked with Kate McKinley who carried out an examination of our current governance arrangements across the following key areas: -
- Organisational Purpose
- Leadership
- Board Behaviour
- Organisation Vision and Values
- Control
- Effectiveness
This was achieved by reviewing our – M&As, Agenda, Board Minutes, Accounts, Policies/Procedures; looking at our Community Development Plan and subsequent reviews; carrying out a skills audit amongst our Directors, which we then followed up with our staff; and undertaking interviews with Directors and staff.
The above culminated in an action plan workshop and we are pleased to report we received extremely positive feedback about our existing systems and people!
Recommended actions are as follows: -
| Organisation Area | Recommended Action | Progress to Date |
|---|---|---|
| Organisational Purpose | Schedule 3-yearly review of governing documents to ensure they remain fit for purpose. | Our Company Secretary is currently reviewing our M&As to ensure they are still fit for purpose. Policies, procedures and your Community Development Plan are already reviewed on an annual basis. |
| Leadership | Consider a once-yearly meeting for directors only to focus on strategy and planning. Alternatively, plan for a strategy day for the whole company – including staff – to give a break from the usual business of directors’ meetings. | We have a plan to bring Directors and staff together during 2022, and our current strategy day title is “Let’s Climb Ben Wyvis” metaphorically speaking! We wanted a title that would inspire us! |
| Board Behaviour | Introduce a Declaration of a Conflict of Interest as a standard agenda item. | Although we have a clear policy to support this, and declarations of interest have historically been noted moving through our agenda and recorded in minutes - we now have this as a standing item on the agenda as recommended. |
| Control |
Include in new director's induction process an indication of the time commitment and yearly schedule of board meetings. |
Achieved. |
|
Development/adaption of a company environmental policy to show how TG&DDC plans to get decarbonise the organisation. |
Our Community Energy Officer, Ewan, has produced a draft policy for our Board’s consideration. Update: 1 August 2022 - Achieved |
|
|
Set a timescale for completion of the review of the Fair Work policy |
We aim to complete this by the end of June 22. Update: 9 June 2022 - Achieved |
|
|
Watch the Running Effective Meetings webinar run as part of this contract may offer some suggestions for shortening meeting times. |
This and the following recommendation made us smile – our board minutes are rather long, but I guess show the amount of work we achieve! |
|
| Introduce a time allocation for each agenda item to avoid lengthy board meetings. The use of a bell to signal the end of each agenda item was a suggestion made at the action plan session and was well received. |
Effective meeting webinar has been shared with Directors and Staff. A bell is in place (see image below) – we have yet to ring it! |
|
| Effectiveness | Possible training for those directors who feel they would benefit from a greater understanding of board finances. The ‘Understanding Finances’ webinar – which is offered as part of this governance health check process – may be useful for this. | Awaiting the link – all Directors and Staff will view the suggested Webinar. Update: Link shared with Directors - 5 June 2022 |
At our Action Plan workshop Kate said:
What stood out was that you have a pretty good functioning board, and you have really good staff, you have projects, and you are well on top of them so there wasn’t anything that caused me alarm.
Great result and always good to be externally evaluated.
Sue, our Chair said:
I want to thank my fellow board Directors and our wonderful Staff for their hard work, which has truly been reflected as part of our involvement with the HIE Board Health Check, Skills and Training Programme.

Last updated: Fri 10 Apr 2026, 08:39
